Consciousness, Pseudo-Consciousness, and the Moral Significance of Consciousness

A widely held picture of consciousness is that (1) there is a deep divide in nature between conscious being and the rest - for some the inner light shines, for others there is only darkness within; (2) there is a legitimate philosophical/scientific project of figuring out the nature of this deep divide; and (3) this project is also of great normative significance, because consciousness is greatly significant both morally/practically and epistemically. This paper presents part of my case for a different, more pluralistic, way of understanding things. On this alternative vision, there is no deep natural divide between conscious beings and the rest. There are many kinds of “inner light”, not united by any deep common thread, and what we call “consciousness” is only one of them. Some may matter more than others, but none is uniquely significant: morally, epistemically, or metaphysically. The paper focuses particularly on the moral significance of consciousness, and defends a pluralistic view of the concept of “phenomenal consciousness”, as well as a pluralism at the metaphysical level.