The Myth of Imaginative Resistance

In discussions of what’s become known as the puzzle of imaginative resistance, philosophers note a surprising asymmetry between our imaginings of factually deviant fictional worlds and our imaginings of morally deviant fictional worlds: While we seem to have no trouble imagining fictional worlds that deviate dramatically from the non-moral facts of actual world, we resist imagining fictional worlds that deviate dramatically from the moral facts of the actual world. Though it is commonly believed that this puzzle raises deep questions about the nature of imagination and its role in our engagement with works of fiction, this paper argues that the puzzle is a myth. Once we bring the discussion back into the fold of our general theorizing about imagination, it becomes clear that the kinds of imaginative failures that are often referred to as instances of imaginative resistance are not at all helpfully thought of in this way.