Introspection and Revelation

According to some formulations of the thesis of revelation, knowledge about the essences of phenomenal properties is available through introspection. But this claim may seem doubtful given relevant limits of introspection. In a number of problematic cases, introspection is not reliable at revealing the metaphysical natures of phenomenal properties. This chapter articulates the worry about revelation arising from these problematic cases of introspective judgements and sketches responses to address it. To respond to the objection, proponents of revelation can draw on existing distinctions between different kinds of introspection which differ in their reliability – first, between thing-introspection and fact-introspection; and second, between simple introspection and complex introspection. The chapter argues that while the kinds of introspective judgements in the problematic cases involve the unreliable forms of introspection, this is not the case with respect to the introspective knowledge or judgements involved in revelation, or at least certain versions of it.