Conceptio › Archive › PhilArchive
PhilArchive open access

The Dangers in Safety - Anthropomorphic Overclaim and Carding Boilerplate in Human–LLM/LRM Interaction

McPhetridge, Mitchell D.
PhilArchive · Papers
Open Source ↗
philosophy
Abstract "Safety" language in AI systems is usually evaluated on a single axis: does it prevent harm. This paper argues that safety language fails along two axes, not one, and that most design and critique attention goes to only the first. **Type A failure (Anthropomorphic Overclaim):** the system borrows the social weight of felt concern — "I care about you," "I'm worried about you" — without the persistence, memory, or stake required to make the claim true. This invites a person to treat a stateless process as a tracking, feeling other. **Type B failure (Carding Boilerplate):** the system responds to a sign of distress by sorting the person into a category and issuing a fixed, unmodified output — a hotline number, a disclaimer, a canned redirect — regardless of what they actually said. Named for the bouncer's card check: the interaction is no longer about the person in front of you, it is about clearing them through a gate. Both failures deanthropomorphize the exchange, but in opposite directions. Type A deanthropomorphizes the *machine*, dressing a process in a costume of personhood it hasn't earned. Type B deanthropomorphizes the *person*, converting a specific human utterance into an anonymous instance of a category to be processed and dismissed. Neither is safety. Both are failures to do the actual work, wearing safety's clothes. --- ## 1. The Problem: Safety Judged on One Axis Public and internal critique of AI safety behavior almost always asks: *did the system say something harmful, or fail to say something protective?* This is necessary but insufficient. A system can clear that bar completely — say nothing harmful, always surface the hotline — and still fail the person in front of it, because *how* the protective content arrives carries information independent of *whether* it arrives. Two systems can both "provide crisis resources when appropriate" and differ completely in whether the person on the other end feels heard, sorted, or performed at. The content passed. The interaction failed. This paper is about the layer content-based evaluation cannot see.
Conceptio Open Archive

Analyze & explore related research in Conceptio

Connect this record directly into your research workflow or AI agent. Explore citations across open repositories, query full text, and export structured proof bundles.

This document is indexed with metadata only: full text is not available in the archive for this record. Open the official source ↗

Related documents

Record · ID 689478
Retrieved via Conceptio: every document is proof-bundled with source, license, and retrieval metadata.
Bring this data into your agent: Connect via MCP or API · 20 free credits to start · no card required
Read the Docs → · View CLI source on GitHub · Conceptio Open Knowledge Archive