Trivalent Conditionals and Quantification

Belnap (1970, 1973) proposed to formalize the restriction of first-order quantifiers ∀ and ∃ by means of a single sentential connective: a trivalent conditional that takes the semantic value ‘void’ when the antecedent is false. Thus, ‘every A is B’ is represented as ∀x(Ax → Bx) and ‘some A is B’ is represented as ∃x(Ax → Bx)—a notable unification compared to the standard representation in first-order logic that uses distinct connectives. This paper implements Belnap’s program, henceforth called Conditional Reduction, in full generality and applies it to all conservative ⟨1, 1⟩ quantifiers. By combining Conditional Reductions with the Conservativity Theorem, due to Keenan and Stavi, any conservative type ⟨1, 1⟩ quantifier turns out to be equivalent to Boolean combinations of three basic type ⟨1⟩ quantifiers (‘everything’, ‘at least λ many things’ and the possessives) scoping over a trivalent conditional.