Defending Awareness and the Substructure of Knowledge: Replies to Aronowitz, Littlejohn, and Neta

It is difficult to convey my gratitude for the time and effort that Sara, Clayton and Ram spent on developing probing and insightful questions about Awareness and the Substructure of Knowledge. I, strangely, know more now about my own project than I did when I wrote it. Despite our disagreements about how some of the questions below are to be answered, I was exceedingly pleased to learn of their varying degrees of openness to and, in some cases, agreement with the central idea that there are factive states that fall short of knowledge. Perhaps these replies will increase our degree of agreement.