Determinate compositionality

First-order logic is obviously compositional. However, given standard syntactic and semantic assumptions, first-order logic does not count as compositional by the standard definition. The standard syntax was handed down by Tarski, but a number of philosophers have suggested that Frege's earlier approach had already provided a way out of this problem with compositionality. Unfortunately, Pickel and Rabern have recently shown that, by itself, this Fregean syntax does not help. However, in this paper, I argue that the Fregean syntax motivates a redefinition of compositionality, and that this combined Fregean package successfully delivers the compositionality of first-order logic. Tarskians can also secure compositionality in a similar way, but only if they adopt a key Fregean idea: bound variables are not semantically significant constituents of the formulas in which they appear.