Killing in The Name Of

Say The Pro-Life View is the position that abortion involves unjustifiedly killing a fetus. And say The Anti-Factory Farming View is the position that factory farms are deeply immoral. One recent objection to The Pro-Life View is that it entails violence against abortion doctors is justified—a view that many find implausible. For the sake of argument, I don’t initially contest this claim—I grant (initially) The Pro-Life View is committed to this position. However, I argue The Anti-Factory Farming View is committed to a similar view, namely, that violence against factory farm workers is justified. Therefore, if this is a good objection to The Pro-Life View, it’s a good objection to The Anti-Factory Farm View. And if it’s not a good objection to the latter, it’s not a good objection to the former. Furthermore, I show why it isn’t crazy to think that violence against abortion doctors is only contingently wrong, and I provide an error theory for why people may think otherwise.