The Gradability of 'Conscious'

Are some creatures “more conscious” than others? A number of consciousness researchers have aimed to answer this question. Yet some have claimed that this question doesn’t even make sense. They claim that ‘conscious’ (in the phenomenal sense) never occurs as a gradable adjective, meaning an adjective that permits degree expressions (‘more F than’, ‘slightly F’, etc.) and that’s associated with a degreed property. Both sides face an explanatory burden: they must explain why some competent speakers seem confused about the meaning of ‘conscious’. We argue that the question does make sense: ‘conscious’ sometimes functions as a minimal-standard gradable adjective. But we will also explain why some theorists have been skeptical about gradable uses of ‘conscious’. Along the way, we address the objection that many gradable constructions involving ‘what it’s like’ expressions are infelicitous, distinguish two interpretations of ‘phenomenal consciousness’, and discuss how our semantic arguments bear on the metaphysical question of whether consciousness comes in degrees.