One Resonance, Symmetrical Perspectives: A Unified Reinterpretation of the Judgemental Triad and the Neurological Basis of Intersubjective Resonance

This paper proposes a new, unified interpretation of the Judgemental Triad (Constructivity (C1), Coherence (C2), and Resonance (R)), the core structure of Judgemental Philosophy (JP). Traditionally, R has been understood primarily as the third axis of judgement or as the "return of meaning." This paper, however, argues that R is a more fundamental, bidirectional, and cyclical process that encompasses C1 and C2 as well. The R (R_out) of one subject, manifested as an "ontological reach" and prepared through their C1 and C2 processes, transforms into an "incoming R" (R_in) from the perspective of an interacting Other, which is then processed through the Other's own C1 and C2. As this reveals the same fundamental flow of R occurring reciprocally, merely with a shift in subject-object perspective, it is argued that C1 and C2 are not isolated cognitive processes but are rather inherent phases or modalities of this larger intersubjective resonant process. This interpretation re-establishes the JT as a truly "R-centric system," emphasizing the inherently relational nature of human judgement and meaning-making. Furthermore, from the viewpoint of this unified resonant process, the phenomenon of Inter-Brain Synchronization, which has recently garnered attention in neuroscience, can be understood as a self-evident neurophysiological manifestation of meaningful intersubjective judgement. This study aims to provide a theoretical deepening of JP and, concurrently, to open new horizons for its empirical investigation.