Cyril, Athanasius, and Pawl on the Human Mental Life of Christ

Timothy Pawl has claimed that various conciliar and patristic texts attribute thinking, willing, suffering, and other human mental states to Christ’s human nature. This article challenges this claim, focusing in particular on the writings of Saints Cyril and Athanasius of Alexandria. I argue that Cyril and Athanasius do not in fact attribute thinking, willing, or any other mental states to Christ’s human nature. Rather, they imply that there is only one individual who thinks Christ’s human thoughts, feels his human pain, speaks his human words, etc. This one individual is not Christ’s human nature but Christ himself, the incarnate divine person. I conclude by highlighting the significance of this historical point for contemporary discussions of the Incarnation in analytic theology and philosophy of religion.