Guideline on dual use and misuse of research for committees for ethics in security relevant research (KEFs)

Foreword The following guideline emerged from the project DUMFE: Dual Use and Misuse of Research Results (“Dual use und Missbrauch von Forschungsergebnissen”), funded by the German Federal Ministry of Education and Research (BMBF, 01GP2187). In recent years, dual use has become a significant issue in research ethics for numerous reasons, garnering considerable attention not only within the ethical community but also in the broader scientific community and among political and security circles. Among the reasons for this attention are the dissemination of scientific developments with high misuse potential, such as gain-of-function experiments (Imai et al. 2012; Herfst et al. 2012; Imperiale and Casadevall 2018); political factors, including recent shifts in the global security landscape (Nationale Akademie der Wissenschaften Leopoldina (Leopoldina) and Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (DFG) 2024, 9ff.); and heightened awareness of historical misuses of science (De Block and Adriaens, 2013). There is detailed advice on the handling of dual use research of concern provided by the Joint Committee (“Joint Committee on the Handling of Security-Relevant Research”) of the German National Academy of Science Leopoldina and the German Research Foundation (DFG) (2022). The Joint Committee also provides networking and exchange opportunities for Committees for Ethics in Security-Relevant Research (Kommissionen für Ethik sicherheitsrelevanter Forschung), so-called KEFs. Nevertheless, additional information and guidance on handling dual use research of concern is a regular request in particular from scientists, but also a request often heard in forums with policy experts, managers and administrators of institutions in research and education. The present guideline provides such additional in-depth information on the definition, examples, legal as well as ethical issues and options for governance of dual use research. It has been written by ethicists and philosophers of technology, supported by lawyers and members of the commission for ethics in research of Forschungszentrum Jülich. It is intended to provide additional information supporting the design of and deliberation in institutional bodies dealing with ethics of security-relevant research. It aims to highlight decisions and options relevant to different institutions and refers to further sources of information throughout.