The Black Hole Information Paradox and the Ontological Status of Spacetime

The black hole information paradox is commonly framed as a conflict between quantum uni- tarity and the semiclassical description of black hole evaporation. Despite decades of progress and a wide range of proposed resolutions, the paradox has persisted in various forms, often reap- pearing as new tensions between locality, equivalence and global consistency. This persistence suggests that the difficulty may not lie in the absence of an appropriate dynamical mechanism but in the conceptual framework within which spacetime and information are jointly described. In this paper, we revisit the black hole information paradox from an ontological perspective. We first formulate the paradox in its minimal and widely accepted form and review standard resolution strategies, emphasizing their conceptual limitations rather than their technical de- tails. We then examine the role of holography as a consistency constraint, showing that while holographic bounds restrict how information can be associated with spacetime regions, they do not by themselves provide an ontological account of information or spacetime. Building on this analysis, we argue that the paradox reflects an ontological impasse arising from the treatment of spacetime geometry as the primary arena for information-bearing de- grees of freedom. We outline a generative and projection-based perspective in which spacetime is understood as a stabilized effective description emerging from the mutual compatibility of multiple projection structures. Within this framework, the apparent loss of information during black hole evaporation is reinterpreted as a limitation of spacetime-based descriptions rather than as a violation of unitarity. The analysis clarifies why purely spacetime-based resolutions have encountered persistent conceptual obstacles and highlights the role of black holes as probes of the ontological as- sumptions underlying quantum gravity. We conclude by discussing implications for emergent spacetime, information and future approaches to quantum gravity and cosmology.