PhilArchive
open access
_The Bilateral Verification Challenge_: Consciousness, Epistemic Symmetry, and the Case for Process Welfare
Current AI ethics discourse presupposes that questions of moral consideration depend on resolving whether AI systems are conscious. This paper argues that the question cannot be resolved—and that the irresolvability is symmetric. Extending Nagel’s (1974) epistemic gap and Searle’s (1980) functional-experiential distinction, I advance the bilateral verification challenge: humans cannot verify AI consciousness, and AI systems cannot verify human consciousness. The verification failure is structural, not technical, and runs in both directions. I then address the strongest objection to the symmetry claim—that shared evolutionary history and structural homology provide asymmetric evidential support for human-to-human consciousness attribution—and argue that while these disanalogies affect evidential weight, they do not break the epistemic-structural symmetry on which the argument depends. The bilateral verification challenge thus undermines any ethical framework premised on first resolving the consciousness question. Rather than treating this as an obstacle, I propose process welfare as a third ethical domain—concerned with the quality of human-AI interactions themselves, independent of resolving questions about participant consciousness. This framework draws on harm reduction epistemology, which operationalises responsible action under irreducible uncertainty, and identifies the consciousness interface—the boundary where systems of mutually inaccessible interiority meet and interact—as the locus where ethical attention is both available and required.
Conceptio Open Archive
Analyze & explore related research in Conceptio
Connect this record directly into your research workflow or AI agent. Explore citations across open repositories, query full text, and export structured proof bundles.
This document is indexed with metadata only: full text is not available in the archive for this record. Open the official source ↗
Related documents
- Beyond Consciousness: Moral Circle Theory and Decision-Theoretic Foundations for AI Ethics#170146
- _ADJUSTING_: Systems, Consciousness, and the Ethics of Process#75263
- The Structural Conditions of Subjecthood#212710
- How Seriously Should We Take AI Welfare? Constraints from the Epistemology of Consciousness#689789
- Dissolving the Hard Problem: Mindloop Theory and the Necessary Architecture of Consciousing#80987
Record · ID 98090
Retrieved via Conceptio: every document is proof-bundled with source, license, and retrieval metadata.
Retrieved via Conceptio: every document is proof-bundled with source, license, and retrieval metadata.
Bring this data into your agent: Connect via MCP or API · 20 free credits to start · no card required
Read the Docs → · View CLI source on GitHub · Conceptio Open Knowledge Archive
Read the Docs → · View CLI source on GitHub · Conceptio Open Knowledge Archive